Hands Down Layout
Hands Down Elan layouts, created in 2020 by R Alan Reiser. Home page at https://www.sites.google.com/alanreiser.com/handsdown/home
The Hands Down layout is not just a layout, but a bad input system.
- It requires a thumb keyboard, but also requires advanced keyboard firmware, such as QMK. [see QMK Configurator Tutorial]
- For certain keys, such as z, you have to type it by pressing j and f at the same time.
- For modifier keys such as Ctrl, it assumes you have set them up using home row keys as dual-purpose keys. [see Problem of Dual-Purpose Keys (home row mods)]
They have several versions.
The Hands Down layouts seem silly and unprofessional. First they put 5 variations on their site. That's like: “come join us, we have 5 ways to swim in arctic ocean for healthy life.”.
Then, you look at their layouts, putting letter in thumb, but none of the variation has the most frequently used e on thumb.
Then, the worst problem is that it require you to type 2 keys together to input some letters. For example:
- press j+f to enter z
- press p+v to enter q
Given the very exotic layouts and non-trivial ways to type z, and requiring fancy batman thumb keyboards [see Do-It-Yourself Keyboards] that requires advanced keyboard firmware such as QMK [see QMK Configurator Tutorial], you find that they don't talk about placement of Backspace ⌫ Delete ⌦ nor Ctrl, Alt. (they advocate that modifier keys be placed on homerow (not shown in their diagrams), so you have Dual-Purpose keys, which by itself introduces other problems. [see Problem of Dual-Purpose Keys (home row mods)] ) The issues of key shortcuts that are far more critical for hand health and software operation efficiency than letter layouts.
When you press f+m fast, it becomes f+l. Because Hands Down has a system it calls Adoptive Keys, which they think makes typing certain 2 letter combination easier. Quote:
You see that Hands Down Layout is no longer a keyboard letter layout, but input system. It requires software that essentially take your input and transform to produce other keys. Also, certain letters such as z, q, no longer has a corresponding key.
When you get into this level of complexity, you need to compare to not other keyboard layouts, but other input systems. For example, abbrev system (such as Microsoft Word auto correction, or emacs's various function templates and name completition [see Emacs: Abbrev Mode] ) , shorthand system (such as the statistics based word completion used in every smart cell phones), math input system [see Design of Math Symbols Input System] , or even comparable to Chinese Input Methods and Japanese Input Method . Also, if you require complex hardware that support Dual-Purpose keys on home row and chording, , then, what stops you from comparing to chording systems such as Stenotype Machine or Using Piano to Type Text?
For example, let's say, you design a keyboard, such that, there are 4 extra dedicated keys under thumb. Each one, are used to insert 4 of the most frequently used words, such as “the”, “and”, “have”, “that”. Will this system, already be more efficient than the Hands Down system?
Xah's conclusion: Hands Down layouts is another ineffectual layout for a handful nerds.