Problem of Dual-Purpose Keys (home row mods)

There is a problem i discovered with dual-purpose key. (same problem with setting your keyboard home row keys as modifiers, aka “home row mods” )

What is Dual-Purpose Key

For some keyboard software, such as UHK Agent used in Ultimate Hacking Keyboard, and QMK firmware [see QMK Configurator Tutorial] and XCAPE [see Linux: Keyboard Software Guide] , and Karabiner-Elements [see Mac Keyboard Tools] etc, They have a feature to assign a modifier key and a non-modifier key both to the same physical key. For example, set Control and Space both to the Space key. When you press and release Space, it inserts a space, but when you press and hold Space, then press for example c, it does Ctrl+c (copy).

What is Home Row Mods

Home Row Mods is setting your home row keys to become modifiers. For example

Problem of Home Row Mods

One problem of Home Row Mods random accidental invocation of key shortcuts, if you are a fast typer.

Problem of Dual-Purpose Keys

When you have a dual-purpose key, you cannot hold the key to repeat.

I know because i used Dual-Purpose Keys on my Gergo Keyboard (QMK firmware), also with on my Ultimate Hacking Keyboard (UHK Agent firmware) .

Gergo keyboard

Ultimate Hacking Keyboard

Try this. Whip your keyboard out. Program the Backspace ⌫ key to be also Ctrl when held down. Now, see if you can hold Backspace ⌫ to delete letters continuously. You can't.

This means, when you have say a 40% keyboard, or even a normal PC form keyboard, am thinking, i'll just set Control to be on QWERTY DF and JK keys, so that i don't even have to use thumb for Control. This works, if you don't mind losing the ability to hold any of d f j k to insert them continuously. But, if the key chosen is one of Space, Backspace ⌫, Delete ⌦, Enter, - , then you may care, because often you do want to hold those keys to repeat them. And this situation happens often when you are on a 40% keyboard such as Gergo Keyboard . Because your thumbs are Backspace ⌫ and Space and Enter etc yet you also want them to be Ctrl or Alt or Shift.

I was a bit annoyed myself when i discovered this. Yes the need to carefully press frequent home row keys for this also annoying. So, i was disappointed to realize that dual-purpose keys isn't as a fantastic idea as i thought. Because i was thinking, why not make every key dual-purpose. Can be done by QMK and Ultimate Hacking Keyboard.

QMK Solution of Dual-Purpose Key Hold to Repeat

2021-04-23 Hans Peter wrote to say that in QMK, the dual-purpose key problem of hold to repeat can be avoided, by press and release the key, then hold it, then the non-modifier function of the key would repeat.

Hold to Repeat is Also a Hack

Keyboard Technology, It's Hack All the Way